Understanding the Difference between HITRUST and HIPAA

In the realm of healthcare information security and compliance, two prominent frameworks stand out: HITRUST and HIPAA. While both are crucial for protecting sensitive data in the healthcare industry, they serve different purposes and have distinct characteristics. This article will delve into the key differences between HITRUST and HIPAA, shedding light on their respective roles and implications for organizations seeking to safeguard sensitive information.

What is HIPAA?

HIPAA, or the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act, was enacted in 1996 to establish standards for the protection of sensitive patient health information. It sets guidelines for healthcare providers, health plans, and other entities to ensure the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of this data. HIPAA includes the Privacy Rule, which governs the use and disclosure of protected health information (PHI), and the Security Rule, which outlines security standards for electronic PHI.

Key Points of HIPAA:

1. Compliance Requirements: HIPAA compliance is mandatory for covered entities and business associates that handle PHI. Failure to comply can result in significant fines and penalties.
2. Focus on Privacy and Security: HIPAA emphasizes the importance of safeguarding patient information to prevent unauthorized access, use, or disclosure.
3. Enforcement: The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) Office for Civil Rights (OCR) is responsible for enforcing HIPAA regulations and investigating breaches.

What is HITRUST?

HITRUST, on the other hand, stands for the Health Information Trust Alliance. It is a private organization that developed the HITRUST Common Security Framework (CSF) to streamline and harmonize various security and privacy standards, including those of HIPAA. HITRUST CSF is a certifiable framework that provides a comprehensive approach to managing security risks and compliance requirements in healthcare.

Key Points of HITRUST:

1. Comprehensive Framework: HITRUST CSF integrates multiple regulations and standards, including HIPAA, to create a unified framework for healthcare organizations.
2. Certification Process: Organizations can undergo a HITRUST CSF assessment and certification to demonstrate their commitment to information security and compliance.
3. Risk Management: HITRUST emphasizes a risk-based approach to security, helping organizations identify and address vulnerabilities proactively.

Comparing HIPAA and HITRUST:  HIPAA and HITRUST CSF are both pivotal in the landscape of healthcare security and compliance. However, they serve different purposes and have distinct approaches to safeguarding protected health information (PHI).

Similarities

Both HIPAA and HITRUST aim to protect sensitive patient information and ensure the privacy and security of healthcare data. Here are some key similarities:

1. Focus on Security and Privacy: Both frameworks emphasize the importance of securing PHI against unauthorized access and breaches. HIPAA sets the baseline standards for data protection, while HITRUST provides a comprehensive framework that builds on these standards.
2. Compliance Requirements: Organizations dealing with healthcare data must comply with HIPAA regulations, and many find that adhering to HITRUST can help meet or exceed these requirements. HITRUST incorporates HIPAA's standards within its broader framework, making it easier for organizations to align with regulatory requirements.
3. Risk Management: Both HIPAA and HITRUST stress the importance of risk management. HIPAA requires covered entities and business associates to conduct regular risk assessments, while HITRUST provides a structured approach to identify, assess, and manage risks through its CSF.

Differences

Despite their similarities, HIPAA and HITRUST have several critical differences:

1. Scope and Framework: HIPAA is a federal law with specific regulations focused on patient data privacy and security. It provides a set of rules that healthcare organizations must follow. On the other hand, HITRUST is a certifiable framework that integrates various standards, including HIPAA, NIST, ISO, and others, offering a comprehensive and scalable approach to information security.
2. Detail and Specificity: HIPAA outlines high-level requirements and leaves much of the implementation details to the discretion of the covered entities. In contrast, HITRUST offers detailed guidelines and best practices, providing a more prescriptive and structured approach to achieving compliance.
3. Enforcement and Accountability: Non-compliance with HIPAA can lead to significant penalties. HIPAA violations can result in fines and legal actions by the Office for Civil Rights (OCR). Many organizations are required to undergo HITRUST certification assessments as part of their contractual obligations. This ensures that organizations maintain high standards of security and privacy.
4. Certification: HIPAA does not have a formal certification process. Compliance is determined through either self-assessments and audits and/or external assessments and audits. Regulatory bodies such as the OCR may also conduct assessments to ensure adherence to HIPAA guidelines. Recently, there has been a trend among organizations to integrate HIPAA requirements with SOC 2 standards, creating a hybrid report known as SOC 2+ HIPAA.  HITRUST, however, offers a certification process through accredited assessors, providing an official validation that an organization meets its comprehensive security and privacy criteria.
5. Flexibility and Adaptability: HIPAA is relatively static, with infrequent updates to its regulations. HITRUST, conversely, is more dynamic and regularly updates its CSF to incorporate new standards, technologies, and threat landscapes, ensuring that organizations can adapt to evolving security challenges.

When to Use Each

Deciding the applicability of HIPAA, HITRUST, or both depends on an organization's specific needs and regulatory environment:

1. HIPAA Compliance: Any organization that handles PHI, including healthcare providers, insurers, and their business associates, must comply with HIPAA. It is the minimum standard required by law and is essential to avoiding breaches and maintaining patient trust.
2. HITRUST Certification: Organizations seeking a more rigorous and holistic approach to security and privacy may opt for HITRUST certification. This is particularly beneficial for entities looking to demonstrate their commitment to high standards of information protection, streamline compliance efforts across multiple frameworks, and gain a competitive edge in the healthcare industry.
3. Combined Approach: Many organizations find value in adopting both HIPAA and HITRUST. By aligning with HIPAA regulations and obtaining HITRUST certification, they can ensure comprehensive protection of PHI, meet multiple regulatory requirements, and establish a robust security posture.

Conclusion

In conclusion, when considering whether to implement HIPAA or HITRUST, organizations must carefully assess their unique requirements and goals. By comprehensively understanding the individual characteristics, commonalities, and distinctions between these frameworks, businesses can make well-informed choices that are in line with their operational objectives and regulatory obligations. While HIPAA compliance is essential for entities primarily operating in the healthcare industry, HITRUST offers a broader, more holistic approach to information security, making it a beneficial option for organizations navigating diverse regulatory landscapes. Elliott Davis stands ready to provide expert guidance and support in implementing either framework, tailored to your specific needs.

‍

The information provided in this communication is of a general nature and should not be considered professional advice. You should not act upon the information provided without obtaining specific professional advice. The information above is subject to change.